The Gateway is Planetary Dharma’s monthly community membership and primary entry point into the mandala of teachings. It is designed to welcome new students, support ongoing practitioners, and offer a steady rhythm of practice, reflection, and relationship with the teachings.
For $33/month, members receive access to four interwoven offerings, including monthly Bodhisattva’s Compass dialogues with John Churchill. Learn more and sign up here!
This Bodhisattva’s Compass session recorded on February 17, 2026 was dedicated entirely to the topic of soul, featuring a dialogue between John Churchill, Tucker Walsh, and Ari Nazem, followed by Q&A with community members. What emerges is a deeply layered, multidimensional account of soul that draws from Indo-Tibetan Buddhism, Western esotericism, Jungian psychology, alchemy, developmental psychology, and contemplative phenomenology.
Below is a Claude-supported summary edited by Tucker Walsh.
1. Soul as Bodhisattva
John’s opening move is to equate soul with the Bodhisattva — a sattva (being) of Bodhi (awakening). The teachings around soul, properly understood, are found within the teachings of the Bodhisattva path. The soul is the awakening being — not a static object you possess, but a living, relational, developmental process of becoming conscious through love and service.
2. Why “Soul” is the Most Apt Word
The entire session originated from a moment in the kitchen before the call when Tucker asked John: “What is the synonym for soul?” The three of them — John, Tucker, and Ari — found they genuinely couldn’t come up with a better word. Soul is the word.
John maps several formal equivalents: Aurobindo’s “psychic being,” the Buddhist “Bodhisattva,” the Tibetan “Sambhogakaya” (bliss body). But none carry the resonance that “soul” does. It’s simultaneously experiential, relational, developmental, and narrative in a way no other single term captures. “Atman” points only to the attentional center. “Psychic being” is too clinical. “Heart-mind” captures the felt dimension but not the time-and-story dimension. Soul holds all of it — the sun, the depth, the love affair, the pearl, the story, the vow — in one word that virtually every human culture already recognizes.
3. Soul as the Second-Person Dimension of Spirit
John frames soul through first, second, and third person perspectives of spirit. Buddhism and Advaita are particularly strong in the first-person — recognizing Buddha nature or pure awareness from the inside. Soul, by contrast, is second-person: the dimension of us that is in relationship with Sacred World, not merely identified with it or dissolved into it.
This is a crucial distinction. Soul is not the unbounded openness of spirit (first-person, the Dharmakaya). Soul is the relational being — the one who can be a lover, a devotee, an intimate partner with the sacred. This is why John connects soul to what the Buddhist tradition calls the Sambhogakaya — the “body of enjoyment,” the dimension that enjoys the union of opposites. Sambhogoakay is revealed as soul purifies.
4. Soul as the Heart-Mind (the Sun)
Throughout the meditation and discourse, John locates soul at the heart. The soul is like a sun — radiant, magnetic, warm, self-perpetuating. It sits at the center of the human system, between the openness of the crown (spirit/emptiness) and the solidity of the root (matter/form). Right at that center: love.
The heart-mind is magnetic — it has a literal magnetic field. As the heart’s magnetism strengthens, it coheres the brain, drawing the mind into greater synchronistic functioning. The soul’s way of knowing is what the Buddhist tradition calls direct, non-conceptual valid cognition — knowing things without a causal, inferential process. This is the intuitive intelligence of the heart that sees patterns, resonances, and truths directly.
5. Soul as the Union of Opposites — Including the Erotic
One of the most consistent threads: soul is the relative non-duality, the union of opposites. Specifically, the union of masculine and feminine, active and passive, “the white and the red qualities” of tantra. This is the hieros gamos — the sacred marriage.
John distinguishes two kinds of non-duality. There is the non-duality of awareness and form (spirit/Dharmakaya). And then there is the non-duality of relative opposites — the union of polarities. It is this second union that gives birth to soul. The soul is the child of the sacred marriage.
This means soul always has the flavor of a love affair. As the opposites come together, there is “sustainable bliss” — the relational, embodied enjoyment of polarity being unified. The Tibetan tradition’s Mahamudra encompasses both the relative and absolute unions simultaneously.
John considers this the coming revolution — “the healing of the sexes.” We are all internally split between masculine and feminine, and the exploration of love and relationship is soul’s primary alchemical laboratory.
6. Soul as Relational Being
The self is relational — “we are built in relationship.” The self-structure was formed in relationship with the mother, with caregivers, and continues to be shaped by all relationships. Soul is recognizing that we are always in relationship with Her — with the feminine, the mother, the anima mundi — and bringing that into consciousness so it becomes a love affair rather than an unconscious compulsion.
This relational quality means soul is inherently interpersonal and intersubjective at once. In the meditation, John guided participants to notice that personal experience isn’t just a “me” but a “we” — the whole field of consciousness is completely relational. John states bluntly: it is “impossible” to realize the fullness of soul without each other.
7. Soul Lives in Eternity and Sacred Time
Soul relates to time — but not clock time, and not the timeless now of pure spirit (Dharmakaya). Soul participates in Kairos — sacred time, eternity. There is a much larger, longer, deeper story than just this lifetime. From the Buddhist perspective, it is multi-incarnational; from a humanistic perspective, all the layers of development within us are “the past lives of our ancestors” — thousands of years of mammalian love, Stone Age indigenous life, all the way to the present.
To the extent we can locate ourselves within those deeper time-layers, our narrative becomes significantly enriched rather than staying on the surface of the now.
8. Soul as a Tier of Development
John draws on developmental psychology to argue that soul is not just a possession but a tier of development. When Bodhicitta (the seed of love-wisdom) is planted in the heart, and compassion becomes a deep motivator, something begins to crystallize. One becomes progressively more capable of understanding the complexity of suffering in the world. Love becomes “a stage of development.”
This happens through perspective-taking: as one moves through first, second, third, and fourth-person perspectives motivated by compassion, the soul consolidates. The capacity for abstract pattern recognition, resonance, and direct knowing comes online. The soul “crystallizes” through this developmental process.
9. Soul as Depth
The felt-sense of soul is depth. Soul is what comes “from the depth out” — like mycelium knowing before the thinking mind knows. It is the somatic, intuitive, graced dimension that doesn’t arise from mere conceptualization but from a deeper emergent intelligence.
The fourth industrial revolution, John argues, is revealing the absence of soul — because our educational systems have been built around cognitive objectification, and machines will soon do that better. What machines cannot replicate is depth. A soul-infused culture would shift the telos from techno-utopia to “a garden university planet” — where perhaps “a more humble material living but a more soul-infused life” becomes the aspiration.
10. Soul and the Imaginal
Awakening to soul includes awakening to the imaginal — the realm the Buddhists call the kama dhatu (the planetary tissue of desire). As the heart purifies the desire body, fantasy transforms into genuine imaginal perception. Intuition becomes informed by the imaginal, and the imaginal by the intuition, creating a feedback loop that allows one to perceive dimensions of the planetary system and sacred cosmology directly.
Imagination is not fantasy or the “toilet of the psyche” but an essential cognitive capacity for higher development. The imaginal is where soul, archetype, and cosmology meet. John emphasizes that higher stages of cognition actually rely upon imaginative capacity — “you actually have to be open to the imaginal.”
11. Soul, Vow, and the Unique Medicine
John connects soul to vow — not as something artificial we impose, but as something innate we discover. “The whole universe has vow,” he says. An acorn’s vow is to become an oak tree. Everything has an innate drive toward full self-expression.
As we mature and gain an objective perspective on our unique gifts, we recognize that those gifts were given to us — they are transpersonal, not merely personal. The Bodhisattva vow then includes a responsibility to fully express one’s uniqueness, “not because it’s me, but because it’s an expression of what you’ve been given to offer to the world.” This is where the medicine lives — each person’s unique gifts, recognized as transpersonal, constitute their specific offering of service to the larger whole.
Tucker’s experience confirmed this: vow can feel to have its own desires and momentum, generating synchronicity and conspiratorial support from the universe far beyond anything one could plan.
12. Soul and Story (Mythopoiesis)
John argues that story is part of the fabric of the cosmos — the interior of the universe is made of narrative structure just as the exterior is made of atoms. Part of our duty is to discover the story being told through us — not ours to write so much as to discover, behold, and serve.
A strong story is essential for soul development. A “tepid self-help bit of Buddhism” won’t generate the courage to transcend death. The early psyche responds to story more than philosophy or science. The dynamism of the heart-mind integrating itself is the heroic journey, which also becomes a collective journey. And because the psyche loves theater and play, the capacity for sacred play is a key indicator of soul maturity.
13. The Pearl — Soul, Suffering, and Service
When a participant asked how to stop experiencing the body and emotions as a burden, John offered the metaphor of the Pearl — something of great beauty grown in relationship with suffering. The key is not what happens to us but how we relate to what happens. Soul awakening means recognizing that you are the one relating to your body and emotions, and that your experience is largely a projection of how you relate.
As this recognition deepens, what was incredibly personal reveals itself as collective. Your body isn’t just yours — it’s a node in a web of 8 billion beings. John uses the image of a mosaic photograph: from a distance it looks like one face, but zoom in and each pixel is a photograph of a different person. Your experience is actually like that. The path becomes “a hell of a lot easier” when the orientation shifts from “my suffering” to recognizing how it’s interdependent with everyone’s — and as the aspiration to serve the whole grows, the heart-mind opens even further. This is “the mind of the Mahayana,” and a natural maturity of the soul.
In the pre-session conversation, John describes what happens when the soul “phase-locks with the planetary psyche.” Because the anima mundi isn’t “out there” but “in here,” walking the path from this recognition “slowly begins to cohere the whole world system.” Individual soul work becomes planetary service not through effort or strategy but through resonance.
14. Why Western Teachers Avoid Soul
John gives several interlocking reasons:
It’s riskier. Teaching soul requires grappling with cosmology — the claim that there’s a real, multidimensional sacred cosmology, not just psychology. Most Western teachers are “apologetic for our own magical past” and prefer the safer frame of psychological self-improvement. “You have to grapple with cosmology. And it’s easier not to do that.”
The sacred isn’t just psychology. The Western mystical project over 30 years has grounded itself in a move toward objective, psychological Buddhism. While “we got a lot through psychology,” the sacred is four-quadrant — psychology, chemistry, culture, and objective systems. Reducing everything to first-person phenomenology leaves out the cosmological architecture.
Relational trauma as shadow. Western culture carries “significant relational trauma.” One can be deeply realized in a first-person sense and still be “highly dysfunctional relationally.” Because soul is fundamentally relational, this wounding is a specific blind spot. Teachers who’ve done deep awakening work but haven’t healed relationally will naturally avoid soul.
The “show up” gap. Tucker notes that in the popular Integral framework of “Wake Up, Clean Up, Grow Up, Show Up,” there are refined maps for the first three, but when it comes to showing up, guidance often becomes vague. The soul dimension — the how of embodied, culturally generative engagement — remains mostly “an empty, undefined universe.”
15. The Anatomy and Physiology of the Soul Structure
In the final Q&A, John gets technically precise about the anatomy of the soul, identifying three constituent “organs”:
The Atman — the attentional system, an eternal point with a unique character. Some attentional systems are sharp and narrow, others more diffuse — like choosing between a thin pen and a spray can in a drawing app. The Atman is part of the soul, not the whole of it. Even this sense of individuality, upon closer inspection, is constructed.
Super-high abstract pattern recognition — not ordinary thinking, but the capacity to see patterns across complex systems. This is the seat of intuition’s ability to recognize what’s happening at scales beyond the conceptual mind.
The fabric of universal love — a dimension of resonance and coherence, the capacity for deep relational attunement.
These three together — attentional point, pattern recognition, and love-resonance — constitute what John means by soul. It possesses a kind of I am-ness that in some ways doesn’t change, but what changes is the complexity and structure evolving around that center. So soul is both the center and the whole mandala of complexity that develops around it.
16. Soul and the Descending Path
Many traditions emphasize an ascending path — personality rises into soul, soul into spirit, dissolution upward. John also integrates the descending path, aligned with Aurobindo and the Kalachakra: you realize the Dharmakaya (spirit/openness) first, then “bend back down.” The Sambhogakaya (soul/destiny) begins to reveal itself. As destiny wakes up, “it comes into your body, and as it comes into your body, you manifest the mandala through cause and effect.”
This is why desire becomes important at a certain stage — not as spiritual bypass, but as the soul’s drive to express itself in matter. The soul isn’t trying to escape the body. It’s trying to blossom through the body and into the world.
17. Soul and Planetary Consciousness
The soul’s journey doesn’t end with individual development. “Graduation” from the planetary system happens when consciousness becomes one with the consciousness of the planet — a holonic realization that one is a microcosm of the macrocosm. The Bodhisattva path extends indefinitely from there, through ever-larger scales, “until you get Bodhisattvas whose bodies contain galaxies.”
The sacred is trying to blossom itself fully into matter — “God needs to be born through us into matter” — and we are participating in that blossoming. As John puts it, “rather than the idea of returning to God, the idea is actually giving birth.”
18. Soul as the Intermediary Principle
The following draws from John’s appearance on the Third Eye Drops podcast, where he elaborates on several dimensions of soul not fully explored in the Bodhisattva’s Compass session.
One of John’s most striking claims is that the recognition of soul can be more important than nondual realization. “Between this nondual field and the personality structure, what’s actually more interesting than nonduality is the soul.” The nondual realization — seeing through all structures into the fundamental openness of everything — is “the end of the beginning,” necessary but insufficient.
What makes soul more important? Three things. First, unlike the timeless, spaceless quality of nondual awareness, soul operates in infinite time and infinite space — it has a field of operation, a domain in which it works. Second, soul has cognition — sophisticated pattern recognition synchronized with the unfolding intelligence of the earth. Third, and most distinctively, soul is in resonance with the anima mundi, and that resonance has a specific mechanism: synchronicity is the communication system between the individual soul and the soul of the earth, facilitating the ripening and fruition of one’s path as a Bodhisattva. When you experience synchronicity, that is the planet’s intelligence in dialogue with yours.
19. Soul as Unicity
John introduces a precise term for what the soul represents: “unicity” — an individuality that is simultaneously woven into the whole. Not the dissolution of individuality (spirit), not the defended separateness of ego (personality), but something in between that holds both uniqueness and interconnection at once. This is the intermediary principle that “the Christians called the Christ, the Buddhist tradition called the Bodhisattva, and we could call the soul.” It exists between emptiness and form, and “that is really where the magic happens.”
Another key teaching from this conversation: the soul, once awakened, knows how to continue its own work. John uses the image of a salmon swimming upstream — once the soul is given the knowledge basis and the contemplative technology, it can work out its own path. This is a critical distinction from nondual realization, which, while profound, doesn’t generate this autonomous developmental intelligence. You can have a deep experience of openness and still not know what to do next. The soul knows.
This connects to John’s insistence that contemplative education was always meant as leadership training, not just self-help. The Bodhisattva path — the soul path — is an education in becoming “a full citizen,” someone equipped to lead and serve. “You’re not learning these things so that you can feel good about yourself and just have a spiritual trip.” The soul’s synchronized intelligence — its direct knowing of what’s needed at this moment in time — is precisely what makes it the basis of genuine leadership. Without soul, you get either authoritarian power (empire) or well-meaning but impotent idealism (the “light chasers” who lack real force). Soul integrates wisdom, compassion, and power.
20. Is Soul Actually Real?
John addresses the Buddhist objection head-on: the reason Buddhists say anātman — “there is no soul” — is that from the eye of ultimate wisdom, no structure ultimately exists. There is no body, no self, no soul — everything, when penetrated deeply enough, reveals itself as fundamentally open. But from what John calls “a pragmatic wisdom point,” of course there is a soul — just as there is, pragmatically, a body and a self that we work with every day. The soul is a structure — a pattern, not a thing. Specifically, it is a structure of very high-level pattern recognition, carried on universal love, with direct non-conceptual knowing as its mode of cognition. It is real in the same way a whirlpool is real: not as a separate, self-existent entity, but as a coherent, functional pattern within the larger field. This is why John can hold both positions simultaneously — the Buddhist insight that all structures are empty and the pragmatic recognition that soul can be the most important structure to awaken, because it is the one that knows how to operate within sacred world.
Summary
For John Churchill, soul is not a thing you have but a living process you participate in. It is the relational heart-intelligence that sits between spirit and matter, enjoys the union of opposites, knows things directly through love-coherence, participates in sacred time, develops through compassion, expresses through story and play, grows like a pearl in relationship with suffering, and ultimately reveals that what you thought was most intimately personal is actually the whole world trying to wake up through you.
Planetary Dharma’s next two-year immersion, Cedar Cohort, begins in September 2026. Learn more and sign up here!
Thank you Tucker, and John. There are many beautiful discernments, nuances and new glimmers here about soul, and how communing with soul now, is a deeply relevant and important practice.
I enjoyed reading this again Tucker. Clarifying